Why Confident People Are Actually More Insecure
Psych 🧠- 339/500
Hey Reader,
ICYMI, Shortform provides the world’s best guides to non-fiction books. They add smart insights, like connecting what one author thinks about another author.Â
You end up understanding the ideas at a super deep level and building these awesome connections between ideas.
They’re offering a 20% discount on annual subscriptions. And hey, trial is free!
What is it?
The research proposes that individuals with fragile high self-esteem are more likely to use verbal defense mechanisms to protect their vulnerable sense of self-worth, while those with secure high self-esteem are less defensive and more accepting of negative feedback.
Major findings:
Fragile high self-esteem predicts greater verbal defensiveness: Individuals with unstable self-esteem, contingent self-esteem (dependent on external validation), or low implicit self-esteem (unconscious negative feelings about oneself) showed higher levels of verbal defensiveness.
Secure high self-esteem associated with less defensiveness: People with stable self-esteem, non-contingent self-esteem, and congruent high implicit self-esteem were significantly less defensive in their verbal responses.
Low self-esteem similar to fragile high self-esteem: Individuals with low self-esteem also exhibited high levels of verbal defensiveness, potentially reflecting difficulty confronting negative self-relevant information.
Verbal defensiveness linked to lower well-being: Higher verbal defensiveness was associated with lower levels of psychological well-being and life satisfaction, suggesting it's a maladaptive coping strategy.
😘 The Only Book You Need to Master Psychology!
The Psych Handbook has 150+ biases & fallacies explained with emojis!
Or an Amazon Kindle copy from here.
What do I need to know:
By understanding the underlying motivations and consequences of verbal defensiveness, we can better support individuals in developing a more resilient and authentic sense of self.
Not all high self-esteem is created equal: The distinction between fragile and secure high self-esteem is crucial for understanding how people respond to threats to their self-image.
Fragile self-esteem fuels defensiveness: People with fragile high self-esteem are highly sensitive to criticism and use various strategies to protect their vulnerable sense of worth.
Secure self-esteem enables acceptance: Individuals with secure high self-esteem are more accepting of their flaws and less threatened by negative feedback.
Verbal defensiveness is a sign of vulnerability: Relying on verbal defense mechanisms can indicate underlying insecurity and ultimately hinder psychological well-being.
Source: